Quantitative research

Finding your voice: tools for better bondholder engagement on climate and nature risk

Written by Andrew Sulston & Josephine Richardson

Download full paper (0.3mb)

Bondholder engagement is becoming an essential part of being a fixed income asset owner or investment manager.

Please view a summary of our toolkit, along with an explanation of how each tool can be applied.

While equity stewardship has historically received much attention, most corporate financing activity takes place in the debt markets, giving bondholders significant power to influence bond issuers. Because fixed income investors are exposed primarily to downside and default risk, the credibility of an issuer’s climate and nature strategy is central to long-term portfolio resilience. At the same time, debt markets differ structurally from equities, characterised by dispersed ownership, and governed by contractual frameworks that require their own engagement approaches.

Against this backdrop, this research paper examines the practical mechanisms, or 'tools', through which asset owners and investment managers can exert meaningful influence, with more collaboration, over bond issuers on transition matters. It identifies 11 engagement tools - grouped under contractual, strategic,  collaborative, and regulatory categories - and these range from bondholder meetings and timing engagement around refinancing windows to the use of indices, and more ambitious investment mandate terms.

Our full assessment explains each of the 11 tools in detail, and explains the detailed feasibility and impact scoring framework used to ascertain the most powerful of the toolkit.

Link to full paper at SSRN (60min read)

The paper also positions these tools within broader themes: the under-utilisation of debt markets for transition engagement, the alignment between transition performance and credit quality, and successes and missed opportunities to date for bondholder engagement. The paper aims to help fixed income teams operationalise engagement in a way that complements thematic and issuer-specific stewardship work.

 

About the authors

Andrew Sulston

Andrew Sulston

Senior Legal Advisor

Based in London, Andrew is a capital markets lawyer focused on AFII’s research and advocacy, particularly the use of law and regulation in market change. He was a partner at Allen & Overy for 18 years.

Josephine Richardson

Josephine Richardson

Managing Director, Head of Research

Based in London, Jo leads AFII’s research and a global team supporting fixed income investors as they align their portfolios with climate and sustainability goals. She joined AFII after 18 years in fixed income markets at JPMorgan.

Before you sign up

By completing this form, you agree to AFII sharing information that we think you may be interested in, including our insights on climate transition. See our Data Protection Policy for more information about how we collect and use your personal data, and any rights you may have in relation to your personal data. You may opt out from our distribution list at any time.